So what's a new kitty-mommy to do? I tried Trader Joe's tonight...and found pretty much what I found with the expensive stuff: one cat likes it, another one, eh.
Sheesh.....you're cats! Just eat it already!!
Well, turns out, they did. Maybe TJ's is OK after all.
(p.s. despite my hard-core blustering, truth is, I really do want my dear life-saving soul-saving heart-rescue companions and friends to enjoy food...so I'm so glad they did.)